We at the Rotokawa Cattle Company have developed an important new tool called a spider graph for evaluating and demonstrating the strengths and weaknesses of a bull or cow's body conformation. The conformation is a critical indicator of how well the animal will function for the producer. I first saw a graph of this type in France, used to illustrate progeny performance in sheep, and applied the concept to evaluating cattle.
What Are Spider Graphs?
Breeding is the art of making pairs, that is, combining complementary traits. Breeders can use our spider graphs to identify weak traits in individual animals and correspondingly strong points in potential mates, to create offspring with a perfected body conformation. Basically we take key measurements of the animal's body, and compare certain measurements to other measurements on the same animal in order to determine key ratios. Then we represent those ratios in a visual layout that makes the animal's breeding potential clear at a glance.
The basic linear measurement approach has been used for centuries to evaluate cattle, but in utilizing and refining it, I have drawn on work done over a period of years by Jan Bonsma, Burl Winchester, Karney Redman and others. Bonsma understood the significance of measurement
and wrote about it in Man Must Measure, Livestock Production, 1983, but the task of distilling Bonsma's ideas into a system fell to Winchester and Redman, who wrote a pamphlet titled Why Measure? in 1988. In recent years, Gearld Fry has popularized this approach, and it was Gearld who introduced me to the importance of linear measurement. Since then I have verified the validity and significance of this system, not only through my field experience throughout North America, New Zealand, Argentina, Uruguay, England, and France, but also through my experience in marketing meat to stores and restaurants throughout the Northeast.
The measurements used for the ratios in the Rotokawa Spider Graphs are rump length, two thirds
body length, total top line, heart girth, flank girth, shoulder width, rump width and hip height. From these eight measurements we determine five key ratios that reveal balance and structural correctness for grass production.
Structural correctness indicates durability and longevity. Animals that are long lived
and will breed back consistently for many years are critical for financial success. Also, the ratios allow us to predict volumes of meat. Animals that exceed the excellence standard indicated on the graph will have a higher percent of meat in the high value
areas of the animal: the loin and rib areas.
How to Use the Graphs
What follows is a description of the graphs, how they are plotted, and how the breeder can use them. This method will indicate the general potential of a particular animal to thrive in a 100% grassfed program, and identify areas of weakness or strength:
1) Heart girth indicates the heart girth compared to top line. The heart girth should be at least equal to the top line,and every inch of heart girth that is greater than the top line adds 37 pounds of red meat to the high value areas of the animal.
Adding heart girth to your meat animals is the easiest way to increase the value of the carcass and earn more money per animal in your herd. The “0” on the spider graph is set at equal; "0" indicates that the heart girth equals the top line.
2) Shoulder width is the comparison of the rump length (not the rump width) totheshoulderwidth. Therumplengthis the measurement from the hooks to the pins,and when compared tothe shoulder widthis indicative ofmasculinityand the presence of testosterone. The male is all about the shoulders. (The female is all about the rump.) The bull should have shoulders at least 2" widerthan therump length as a young bull, and a mature bull should have shoulders at least 4" wider than the rump length. The
"0" on the spider graph is set at +2", the minimum for a good bull.
3)Rump width % is the comparison of the hip height of the bull to the rump width. A higher percentage is indicative of volume of meat in the rump area. We expect the bull to be 44% as wide as he is tall. Wider is better. The "0" on the spider graph is set at 44%.
4) Flank girth is a comparison of the flank girth to the heart girth. On a bull, we would like to see these numbers be equal. An "0" on the spider graph indicates that the flank girth equals the heart girth. Equal is the ideal, but bulls will be greater or less in this measurement.
5) Rump length % is the comparison
of the rump length to the two-thirds
body length of the bull. This two-thirds
length is measured from the rear of the animal to the point on the back bone
directly above the point of the shoulder.
The "0" in the spider graph is set at 37%.
Remember all animals have strong points
and weak points. Each spider graph shows
an excellent standard compared to ratios
of a particular animal that may fall short
of the standard or may exceed it. These
graphs will help producers make more
informed choices on breeding. All of our
the Rotokawa® bulls are "prepotent," that
is, they have the "bull power" to impact
their offspring in a consistent way, but
they do have different strengths. You can
see from the spider graphs which ones
are stronger in the heart girth, rump
width percent, and in the shoulder
measurements.
In summary our Rotokawa spider graphs
provide specific criteria for breeding
decisions that can be documented and
communicated to others.
